Oversight Board Defies Council, Installs Rebecca Kemble as Interim Police Monitor
The Police Civilian Oversight Board appointed the former alder and author of the oversight ordinance in a special meeting — a rebuke to the Common Council, whose leaders question whether the board has that power.

Madison's Police Civilian Oversight Board has provisionally appointed former alder Rebecca Kemble as the city's interim independent police monitor, reasserting its own authority in a direct rebuke to the Common Council.
The appointment came in a special meeting Monday night, capping weeks of open conflict between the board and council members who had moved to terminate the previous interim monitor, Meeka Glass, before the end of her contract. The oversight board has argued that the power to hire and fire the monitor belongs to it, not the council.
Kemble is no neutral caretaker. She served on the council from 2015 to 2021 and was a core member of the alder workgroup that wrote the 2020 ordinance creating both the oversight board and the Office of the Independent Monitor — making her, in effect, the returning author of the system she will now run.
I thought, my God, we're finally doing it. Do you know how precious this is?
“This body has been administratively captured until recently,” Kemble told the council during an earlier round of the fight, describing her tears on reading the monitor's first report: “I thought, my God, we're finally doing it.”
City officials have publicly questioned whether the board's appointment will stick, setting up a likely legal and political test of where oversight power actually sits. For residents, the practical question is simpler: the office that fields complaints about police conduct now has a new — and very familiar — name on its door.


