Madison Gazette

From the Square to the wider world

Madison

Judge Dismisses Homicide Charge in October Shooting on Pinckney Street

The first-degree intentional homicide case in the death of Daundre Young Johnson was dismissed without prejudice on Friday, leaving prosecutors free to refile. The district attorney says the investigation remains open.

The limestone columns and wide stone steps of a county courthouse on an overcast morning
A Dane County judge signed the order of dismissal on Nov. 13. The district attorney says the investigation into the Oct. 24 shooting continues. AI-generated illustration for Madison Gazette

A Dane County judge on Friday dismissed the first-degree intentional homicide charge against a 28-year-old man accused in the fatal shooting of Daundre Young Johnson last month on South Pinckney Street — a dismissal without prejudice that leaves prosecutors free to bring the charge again.

Judge Nicholas McNamara signed the order of dismissal on Nov. 13, according to WKOW. The charge was dismissed without prejudice, court documents show, meaning the state may refile it if prosecutors choose. Bond in the case had been set at $1 million, according to earlier Channel 3000 reporting.

Madison police said the shooting happened during a fight on Pinckney Street on Oct. 24. Officers found Johnson, 27, with a gunshot wound in the 100 block of South Pinckney Street early that morning; he died at a hospital later that day.

The investigation remains open, and prosecutors retain the option of refiling the charge.

The Gazette is withholding the name of the man who had been charged because he no longer stands accused in the case. WKOW made the same decision in its reporting, while other outlets have published the name from court records.

Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne told Channel 3000 that the investigation remains open and that his office will continue reviewing evidence. A dismissal without prejudice is not an acquittal; prosecutors retain the option of charging the same defendant again or charging another person as the investigation develops.

Johnson's death was one of a string of downtown gun incidents this fall that has kept the isthmus on edge, and the dismissal leaves the case without an active defendant. Police have not announced additional arrests.

homicide dane county court pinckney street downtown courts

← Back to the front page