Madison Gazette

From the Square to the wider world

Nation

White House Warns Democrats That Planned Investigations Could 'Cross the Line Into Blatant Criminality'

The White House counsel told the incoming House oversight chairman that some planned probes could be criminal. Legal experts across the spectrum are skeptical.

The United States Capitol under an overcast sky, seen across the Reflecting Pool
A capital braced for a subpoena winter. AI-generated illustration for Madison Gazette

The White House has warned the incoming Democratic chairman of the House Oversight Committee that investigations planned for the next Congress "may cross the line into blatant criminality," an extraordinary escalation weeks before Democrats take control of both chambers of Congress.

The warning came in a letter dated Monday from White House counsel Will Scharf to Rep. Robert Garcia of California, first reported by Punchbowl News. Scharf wrote that congressional subpoenas "designed merely to abuse or instill fear in the recipient" could be criminal and that "issuing unlawful subpoenas" might warrant further investigation.

"Compulsory process is a power Congress has for oversight functions, and only for oversight functions," Scharf wrote, citing the Supreme Court's decisions in Watkins v. United States and Trump v. Mazars. He accused Democrats of making "abusive and capricious threats" against executive branch officials.

It appears Donald Trump has something to hide.

Garcia, who is set to chair the Oversight Committee when the new Congress convenes in January, answered in kind. "It appears Donald Trump has something to hide," he said in a statement. "Congress' authority comes from Article I of the Constitution, not from the permission of the White House." He had earlier told administration officials to "lawyer up."

The Justice Department has echoed the approach. Politico reported that a U.S. attorney sent a similar letter Wednesday to Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut over his inquiry into donors behind the White House ballroom project, followed Thursday by a letter to Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan. Blumenthal called the threat baseless.

Legal experts across the ideological spectrum questioned the criminal framing. Ilya Shapiro of the Manhattan Institute told Fox News that prosecutions are "a very different animal that face a higher bar," while the Cato Institute's Molly Nixon said the letter "isn't on solid ground" in suggesting criminality. Lawmakers also enjoy broad Speech or Debate Clause protections.

The exchange previews a combative two years in Washington. Democrats won House and Senate majorities in this month's midterms, and oversight committees have already sought records on the business ventures of the president's family and allies, as well as pardons granted to major donors.

White House congress oversight Robert Garcia Trump administration

← Back to the front page